Active treatment vs maintenance care in Medicare chiropractic billing

Where CMS draws the line between active, corrective chiropractic care and maintenance therapy, how to document improvement while care is active, and what changes on the claim and the payment conversation when care crosses it.

CMS: when no further clinical improvement is expected

Where the line sits

Supportive vs corrective care

Not medically reasonable or necessary under Medicare

Maintenance pay status

Not payable

98940-98942 claims without it are denied as maintenance

Active-treatment flag

AT modifier

GZ lines auto-deny without complex medical review

ABN-backed line

GA modifier

Maintenance care under Medicare begins when chiropractic manipulation billed as 98940, 98941 or 98942 stops being corrective. CMS draws the line at expected clinical improvement: while continued manipulation is expected to produce functional improvement, the care is active treatment billed under the AT modifier. Once clinical status is stable with no objective improvement expected, the same manipulation is maintenance therapy: not medically reasonable or necessary under Medicare, and not payable. This guide covers where the line sits, how to document improvement, and what changes on the claim when care crosses it.

What active treatment and maintenance care mean under Medicare

Medicare's chiropractic benefit is narrow to begin with.

The coverage rule, 42 CFR 410.21(b), limits Part B payment to a chiropractor's manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation that has resulted in a neuromusculoskeletal condition.

The covered claims are CPT 98940, 98941 and 98942 (spinal manipulation across 1-2, 3-4 or 5 regions), and Medicare MAC billing articles list those three codes as the covered manipulation codes.

CMS's maintenance definition decides when even that covered service stops being payable.

In the Benefit Policy Manual, when further clinical improvement cannot reasonably be expected from continuous ongoing care and chiropractic treatment becomes supportive rather than corrective, the treatment is maintenance therapy.

CMS frames maintenance as care that seeks to prevent disease, promote health, prolong or enhance quality of life, or maintain or prevent deterioration of a chronic condition.

The consequence is blunt: under the Medicare program, chiropractic maintenance therapy is not considered medically reasonable or necessary, and is therefore not payable.

The line is expected improvement, not the diagnosis.

A chronic subluxation can still support active treatment when continued therapy is expected to produce some functional improvement.

Once clinical status has remained stable without expectation of additional objective clinical improvements, further manipulative treatment is maintenance and is not covered.

There is a clock on the front end too.

CMS's guidance says acute subluxation problems such as strains or sprains may require as many as three months of treatment, with visit frequency expected to decrease over time.

An episode that keeps running at unchanged frequency past that acute pattern is where the maintenance question arrives.

The record is what answers it, since the switch CMS defines turns on clinical status and expected improvement rather than on visit counts.

For the rest of the Medicare picture (covered codes, subluxation demonstration, par versus non-par), see the practice guide to Medicare chiropractic billing, and the chiropractic billing and coding workflow it sits inside.

Signs a Medicare patient's care has become maintenance

CMS's own test gives the first sign.

Once clinical status has remained stable for a given condition, without expectation of additional objective clinical improvements, further manipulative treatment is considered maintenance therapy and is not covered.

The other signs follow from the definition.

The stated purpose of continued care has shifted from correction to support (maintaining function, preventing deterioration, promoting health) rather than measurable change in the condition being treated.

Visit patterns are a signal too, though not a rule by themselves.

CMS's guidance expects frequency to decrease as an acute episode resolves, so a schedule that holds steady after the record stops showing change is the combination worth reading closely.

The audit history explains why the line matters to a practice.

OIG found $76 million in questionable Medicare payments for chiropractic services in 2013, and almost half of the questionable payments were for claims suggestive of maintenance therapy.

In the same findings, 2 percent of chiropractors were responsible for half of the questionable payments, and past OIG work found that between 40 and 47 percent of all paid chiropractic claims were for maintenance therapy.

Those figures are dated (the OIG report covers 2013), and this page cites no newer count, but they show why the active-versus-maintenance line draws audit attention: manipulation billed as active treatment after the record has stopped showing expected improvement.

Documenting progress while care is still active

The treatment plan is where the active-versus-maintenance case starts.

CMS expects a chiropractic treatment plan to state the recommended level of care (the duration and frequency of visits) along with specific treatment goals and objective measures to evaluate effectiveness.

Subsequent visits then have to keep score.

CMS's requirements for subsequent visits are a history reviewing the chief complaint and changes since the last visit (with a system review if relevant).

They also cover a physical exam of the involved spinal area that assesses change and treatment effectiveness, and documentation of the treatment given that day.

Two contractor notes keep the workload realistic.

CGS, a Medicare administrative contractor, says a full repeat PART exam is not expected at every subsequent visit, but the note should show how that day's treatment fits the plan, in the style of “visit 4 of planned 7 treatments.”

Noridian likewise says medical necessity can be supported by recording each visit as part of an ordered sequence in the treatment plan, for example “#4 of ten planned adjustments.”

For the objective measures, CGS lists standardized outcome scales as acceptable ways to measure improvement: the Visual Analogue Scale, the Oswestry Disability Questionnaire and the Quebec Back Pain Disability Scale.

That record does double duty.

While improvement continues, it supports the AT-modified claim.

When it shows a plateau (stable status, no expected objective gain), the same documentation is what tells the practice and the patient that the next visit is maintenance in Medicare's terms.

The modifier and ABN switch when care crosses the line

On the claim, active and maintenance care separate at one modifier.

Medicare requires the AT modifier when the chiropractor is providing active, corrective treatment of an acute or chronic subluxation, and claims for 98940, 98941 or 98942 without the AT modifier are treated as maintenance therapy and denied.

The flag is not a guarantee.

CMS notes the AT modifier alone does not guarantee a service is reasonable and necessary, and Palmetto GBA instructs the other side of the same rule: the AT modifier must not be used when the treatment performed was maintenance.

When care crosses the line and the patient wants to continue, the ABN is CMS's mechanism for putting the cost question to the beneficiary.

An ABN (Form CMS-R-131, with the current English form showing expiration 03/31/2029) is issued to Original Medicare beneficiaries when Medicare payment is expected to be denied, transferring potential financial liability to the beneficiary.

CMS's handling instructions are specific.

The patient must sign and date the notice, and it cannot be completed in advance of the service.

The practice gives the patient a copy and retains its own copy of the signed ABN.

The claim then carries the right modifier.

CMS directs chiropractors who give an ABN to follow Claims Processing Manual chapter 23, section 20.9.1.1 and include the GA modifier (or, in rare instances, GZ).

GA indicates the provider expects a not-reasonable-and-necessary denial and has a signed ABN on file; GZ indicates the expected denial with no signed ABN.

Since July 1, 2011, MACs automatically deny claim lines billed with GZ, without complex medical review, and a line carrying both GA and GZ is unprocessable.

WPS, a Medicare administrative contractor, adds the in-between case: when a chiropractor bills with AT but believes the service is likely to be denied as not medically necessary, the beneficiary signs an ABN and the claim carries the GA modifier.

One boundary keeps the categories straight.

ABNs are not required for care that is statutorily excluded (services Medicare never covers at all), though CMS strongly encourages issuing them voluntarily there.

Maintenance manipulation is a different category: a potentially covered service denied as not reasonable and necessary, which is why the ABN process is the one that applies to it.

Maintenance care as cash: paying outside the Medicare claim

For the patient who wants to keep coming after improvement has plateaued, payment moves off the Medicare claim.

Maintenance therapy is not payable under Medicare, and the ABN-backed line (modifier GA, denial expected as not reasonable and necessary) is how the beneficiary takes on the cost of continued visits.

Folding Medicare patients into a cash-only model is not the alternative.

CMS states that chiropractors may not opt out of Medicare and provide services under private contract, and federal law requires a claim to be submitted on the beneficiary's behalf within one year of a Part B service while barring charges for completing the form.

Spinal manipulation that is still active, corrective care still runs through a Medicare claim.

The rest of a chiropractic visit was never in the benefit.

WPS's list of services excluded from Medicare when performed by a chiropractor names lab tests, x-rays, office visits (history and physical), physiotherapy, traction, supplies and nutritional counseling.

Offices may submit those charges to obtain a denial, which WPS notes is necessary for submitting to a secondary insurance carrier.

ABNs are optional for statutorily excluded care like this, though CMS encourages issuing them voluntarily.

Self-pay pricing for maintenance plans can bring its own federal rule set.

Under the No Surprises Act, providers must inform uninsured or self-pay individuals that a good faith estimate is available on scheduling or request.

The estimate is due within 1 business day of scheduling when the service is scheduled at least 3 business days out, and within 3 business days when scheduled at least 10 business days out.

A request for an estimate triggers one within 3 business days.

For recurring services such as a care plan, a good faith estimate may cover no more than 12 months, with a new estimate issued beyond that.

Those estimate rules are written for uninsured or self-pay individuals.

Our research did not establish whether a Medicare beneficiary whose maintenance visits still go to Medicare on an ABN-backed GA claim falls in that group, so confirm that with counsel before building it into the workflow.

Employer information, not legal, tax, billing, coding or insurance advice. Confirm Medicare's coverage, modifier and ABN requirements with CMS and your MAC, and have a certified coder and counsel review the practice's documentation, notice and self-pay processes before building workflows around them.

Before a Medicare patient continues maintenance visits out of pocket

  • The record documents stable clinical status with no additional objective improvement expected from continued manipulation
  • The treatment plan's goals reflect what continued care is for — maintenance rather than correction
  • A signed, dated ABN (Form CMS-R-131) is on file; CMS's instructions bar completing the form in advance of the service
  • The claim carries the GA modifier, and the AT modifier stays off visits where the treatment given was maintenance
  • Counsel has confirmed whether the No Surprises Act good faith estimate rules, written for uninsured or self-pay individuals, apply to these ABN-backed visits

Questions employers ask

Does Medicare pay for maintenance chiropractic care?

No, Medicare does not pay for maintenance chiropractic care. CMS treats chiropractic maintenance therapy (care that has become supportive rather than corrective once further clinical improvement cannot reasonably be expected) as not medically reasonable or necessary, and therefore not payable. Claims for spinal manipulation billed without the AT modifier are also treated as maintenance therapy and denied.

What happens if a Medicare chiropractic claim is missing the AT modifier?

Claims for 98940, 98941 or 98942 without the AT modifier are treated as maintenance therapy and denied. The modifier signals active, corrective treatment of an acute or chronic subluxation, and Palmetto GBA, a Medicare administrative contractor, instructs that it must not be used on a visit where the treatment given was maintenance.

Can a Medicare patient pay out of pocket for maintenance chiropractic visits?

Yes, a Medicare patient can pay out of pocket for maintenance visits through CMS's ABN process, which covers visits expected to be denied as not medically necessary. Medicare does not pay for maintenance therapy. The patient signs and dates the notice (it cannot be completed in advance), the practice keeps a copy, and the claim carries the GA modifier. Confirm the specifics with your MAC.

How long does Medicare cover chiropractic treatment for an acute problem?

CMS's guidance says acute subluxation problems such as strains or sprains may require as many as three months of treatment, with visit frequency expected to decrease over time. The switch to maintenance is defined by clinical status rather than by a visit count: care becomes maintenance once status is stable without additional objective improvement expected.

What documentation shows a Medicare chiropractic patient is improving?

CMS expects the treatment plan to name objective measures of effectiveness, and subsequent-visit notes to assess change and treatment effectiveness. CGS, a Medicare administrative contractor, lists standardized scales (the Visual Analogue Scale, Oswestry Disability Questionnaire and Quebec Back Pain Disability Scale) as acceptable ways to measure improvement.

More hiring resources

Hiring for your practice?

The modifier, ABN and documentation steps on this page are the work a billing specialist and a disciplined front desk handle. List your opening where doctors of chiropractic, chiropractic assistants and billing staff look for their next role.