GA vs GZ modifiers for chiropractors: ABN on file or not

The difference between the two Medicare modifiers is one document: a signed Advance Beneficiary Notice. What each one tells the contractor, how the choice plays out on maintenance care, and where patient liability lands after the denial.

used when Medicare is expected to deny the service as not reasonable and necessary

GA modifier

Signed ABN on file

lines billed with GZ auto-deny without complex medical review

GZ modifier

No signed ABN

current English form shows expiration 03/31/2029

The ABN form

CMS-R-131

CMS encourages voluntary ABNs; GY carries those lines, GX when a voluntary ABN is issued

Statutorily excluded services

ABN optional

The GA and GZ modifiers mark Medicare claim lines expected to deny as not reasonable and necessary: GA when a signed ABN is on file, GZ when none was signed, a line A/B MACs have auto-denied since July 1, 2011. Both belong to the expected-denial situation, and for chiropractic claims this page works through its maintenance-care version. Medicare treats maintenance therapy as not medically necessary, GZ lines auto-deny without complex medical review, and GA puts the signed notice (and the beneficiary's potential liability) on record.

What the GA modifier means

The GA modifier is Medicare's "ABN on file" flag: it tells the contractor reading the claim that a denial is expected and the signed waiver notice already exists.

CGS, one of Medicare's Administrative Contractors (MACs), defines the GA modifier as "Waiver of Liability Statement Issued as Required by Payer Policy."

In CGS's chiropractic billing article, GA goes on the claim when the provider anticipates that Medicare will deny a specific service as not reasonable and necessary, and has an ABN signed by the beneficiary.

CMS carries the same pairing in its Benefit Policy Manual: chiropractors who give a beneficiary an ABN follow Medicare Claims Processing Manual chapter 23, section 20.9.1.1, and include GA (or, in CMS's wording, in rare instances GZ) on the claim.

Both halves of the definition do work: the expected denial is the situation, and the signed ABN is what the modifier attests to.

GA describes a claim with the notice in the file; where no notice was signed, the matching modifier is GZ, not GA.

What the GZ modifier means

GZ reports the same expected denial with the paperwork missing.

In CGS's article, the GZ modifier goes on the claim when the provider expects Medicare to deny the item or service as not reasonable and necessary and has not had an ABN signed by the beneficiary.

What happens to that line is fixed by CMS's own Claims Processing Manual.

Effective for dates of service on and after July 1, 2011, A/B MACs automatically deny claim lines submitted with a GZ modifier.

MACs deny those lines without complex medical review: the judgment is built into the modifier itself, not made claim by claim.

A line carrying both GA and GZ is unprocessable.

So GZ is not a route to payment and not a request for a medical-necessity review; it is a declaration that no ABN was signed, attached to a line that will deny by design.

GA vs GZ for maintenance care

Maintenance care is where the expected-denial situation comes from in a chiropractic practice.

Medicare counts a chiropractor as a "physician" only for treatment by manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation, billed as 98940 (1-2 spinal regions), 98941 (3-4) or 98942 (5).

CMS defines maintenance therapy as care that prevents disease, promotes health, or maintains or prevents deterioration of a chronic condition; once care becomes supportive rather than corrective, it is maintenance.

Medicare treats chiropractic maintenance therapy as not medically reasonable or necessary, so it is not payable.

The line runs on clinical status and expected improvement: a chronic subluxation can still be active treatment while continued therapy is expected to produce some functional improvement, and once clinical status has remained stable without expectation of additional objective improvements, further manipulation is maintenance.

The AT modifier is what tells Medicare which side of that line a claim sits on.

Medicare requires AT on claims for active or corrective treatment of an acute or chronic subluxation, and a claim for 98940, 98941 or 98942 without AT is treated as maintenance therapy and denied.

Palmetto GBA, another MAC, states the other direction: the AT modifier must not be used when maintenance therapy has been performed.

On a maintenance visit, then, the claim goes out without AT, the denial is expected, and the GA-or-GZ choice records whether an ABN was signed first: GA with the signed form on file, GZ without one.

WPS adds a rule for the active-treatment side: if the provider bills the AT modifier but believes the service is likely to be denied as not medically necessary, the beneficiary must sign an ABN and the claim must carry GA.

Not every line a practice expects to deny is a GA-or-GZ line.

WPS notes that offices may submit services excluded from Medicare when performed by a DC — the list includes x-rays, office visits, physiotherapy, traction and supplies — to obtain a denial for secondary insurance.

Those excluded lines are the GY-and-GX situation covered under patient liability below, not GA or GZ.

Patient liability when Medicare denies

The ABN is the document that decides where potential liability for a denied amount sits.

CMS describes the Advance Beneficiary Notice, Form CMS-R-131, as the notice issued to Original Medicare beneficiaries when Medicare payment is expected to be denied, to transfer potential financial liability to the beneficiary.

The current English form shows an expiration date of 03/31/2029 and OMB No. 0938-0566.

CMS's instructions are specific about how the form gets executed: the patient signs and dates the notice, and the notice cannot be completed in advance.

The provider gives the patient a copy and retains a copy of the signed ABN.

That signed form is the fork between the two modifiers.

With GA, the denial arrives with the ABN already in the file, and the potential liability CMS describes sits where the form put it — with the beneficiary.

With GZ, no ABN was obtained: the notice that transfers potential liability is missing, and the line auto-denies.

One boundary keeps the two situations apart.

ABNs are not required for care that is statutorily excluded from Medicare (care that is never covered), though CMS strongly encourages issuing them voluntarily for such care.

For a chiropractor, that excluded bucket is wide: Medicare Part B does not pay for x-rays or any other diagnostic or therapeutic service furnished or ordered by a chiropractor.

Maintenance CMT sits in the other bucket (denied as not reasonable and necessary rather than excluded), and that is the bucket where the signed ABN is what places the potential liability on the beneficiary instead of the practice.

On excluded lines the modifier set changes with the situation: GY is the modifier for statutorily non-covered services with no benefit category, and GX flags a voluntary ABN for such services; both lines auto-deny.

GA and GZ belong to the reasonable-and-necessary denial, not to the statutory exclusion.

Common GA and GZ errors

The GA and GZ mistakes that matter are mechanical, and each has a definition behind it.

  • Both modifiers on one line: unprocessable.
  • Counting on a GZ line to be reviewed: it auto-denies, without complex medical review, as it has since July 1, 2011.
  • GA where no signed ABN exists in the file: the modifier attests to a signed ABN, and GZ is the one defined for the claim without it.
  • AT on a maintenance visit: Palmetto GBA states the AT modifier must not be used when maintenance therapy has been performed.
  • AT missing on an active-treatment visit: the claim is treated as maintenance therapy and denied.
  • An ABN assumed to be mandatory for a service Medicare never covers: ABNs are not required for statutorily excluded care, and GY (with GX for a voluntary ABN) is the modifier pair for those lines.
  • ABN paperwork slips: a form without the patient's signature or date, or one completed in advance, does not meet CMS's instructions for a signed, dated notice with a copy given and a copy retained.

Two cautions keep the rest of the claim cycle honest.

GA and GZ are Medicare machinery: the definitions above come from CMS manuals and MAC articles.

Do not assume they carry over to commercial payers; confirm each payer's own modifier instructions before you submit.

For where the modifiers sit in the full claim cycle, our chiropractic billing and coding page walks the whole cycle.

Medicare's coverage rules (what Part B pays a chiropractor for, the subluxation and diagnosis rules, the AT-and-maintenance pairing) are on Medicare chiropractic billing.

And if the person making these modifier calls sits in your billing seat, browse chiropractic billing specialist jobs to see what candidates see.

Employer information, not billing, coding, legal or tax advice. The modifier and ABN rules above come from CMS manuals and the MAC articles named; a practice should confirm its own modifier and ABN questions with CMS, its MAC and a certified coder.

The GA-or-GZ decision, in order

  • Is the service expected to be denied as not reasonable and necessary (for example, the maintenance-care situation above)? If no denial is expected, neither modifier's definition applies.
  • Signed ABN in the file, signed and dated by the patient? The line carries GA.
  • No signed ABN? The line carries GZ and auto-denies, and a line carrying both GA and GZ is unprocessable.
  • Service Medicare never covers at all, with no benefit category? GY on the line; GX when a voluntary ABN was issued.
  • Active or corrective treatment keeps the AT modifier; a maintenance visit drops it.

Questions employers ask

When does a chiropractor use the GA modifier?

A chiropractor uses the GA modifier when Medicare is expected to deny a service as not reasonable and necessary and a signed ABN is on file. CMS instructs chiropractors who give a beneficiary an ABN to follow Medicare Claims Processing Manual chapter 23, section 20.9.1.1 and include the GA modifier (or, in rare instances, GZ) on the claim. For chiropractors the claims in question are the spinal CMT codes 98940-98942; when that care is maintenance, Medicare treats it as not medically reasonable or necessary.

What does the GZ modifier mean on a chiropractic claim?

The GZ modifier means the provider expects Medicare to deny the item or service as not reasonable and necessary and has not had an ABN signed by the beneficiary. Since July 1, 2011, Medicare's A/B MACs automatically deny claim lines submitted with a GZ modifier, without complex medical review, and a line carrying both GA and GZ is unprocessable. GZ records the missing ABN; it does not ask for a medical-necessity review.

Do claims billed with the GZ modifier ever get paid?

No, not under Medicare's own rule for them: since July 1, 2011, the Claims Processing Manual has directed A/B MACs to automatically deny claim lines submitted with a GZ modifier, without complex medical review. The modifier's job is to report that no signed ABN is on file for a service expected to be denied. Where a practice wants the denial documented with the beneficiary's potential liability on record, that is the GA modifier's pairing with a signed ABN.

Is an ABN required for services a chiropractor provides that Medicare never covers?

No. CMS states ABNs are not required for care that is statutorily excluded from Medicare (care that is never covered), though it strongly encourages issuing them voluntarily. On those lines the modifiers are GY for the excluded service and GX when a voluntary ABN is issued, and both lines auto-deny. Maintenance CMT is a different denial (not reasonable and necessary rather than excluded), which is where GA with a signed ABN carries the liability transfer.

What form is the Medicare ABN?

The Medicare ABN is Form CMS-R-131. The current English form shows an expiration date of 03/31/2029 and OMB No. 0938-0566. CMS's instructions for issuing it: the patient signs and dates the notice, the notice cannot be completed in advance, the provider gives the patient a copy, and the provider retains a copy of the signed form.

More hiring resources

Hiring the people who make these modifier calls?

List your chiropractic billing specialist, front desk and office manager openings on a chiropractic-only job board.